Matters at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher
Bovat v. Vermont
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 19-1301 (brief filed June 17, 2020)
Client: The Institute for Justice, amicus curiae supporting the petitioner
Role: As an associate at Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter drafted the brief.
What the brief argued: State game wardens walked up a driveway and looked into a garage to inspect a truck without a warrant, and the Vermont Supreme Court upheld the search under a “semiprivate areas” rule. The brief argued that under Florida v. Jardines and United States v. Jones, the implied license to approach a home lets officers do only what an ordinary visitor may do, and that the Vermont rule turns the knock-and-talk exception into a license to search.
Result: Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Kagan, wrote a statement respecting the denial of review explaining that the Vermont court had erred: “Under Jardines, there exist no ‘semiprivate areas’ within the curtilage where governmental agents may roam from edge to edge.” Bovat v. Vermont, 141 S. Ct. 22, 24 (2020) (statement of Gorsuch, J., respecting the denial of certiorari).
Documents: the brief (supremecourt.gov); Justice Gorsuch’s statement (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: Constitutional litigation; Amicus briefs
