Matters
Showalter PLLC matters
Suncor Energy (U.S.A.) Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County
Supreme Court, 2026. Amicus brief for the Breakthrough Institute supporting the petitioners.
Younge v. Fulton Judicial Circuit District Attorney’s Office
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 25-352 (brief filed August 10, 2026)
Client: Michael J. Showalter, as amicus curiae supporting the respondent
Role: Michael Showalter wrote the brief and filed it as counsel of record.
What the brief argued: The case asks whether a district court may consider an affirmative defense at summary judgment when the defendant did not plead it and the plaintiff suffers no prejudice. The brief argued that a court may do so without any amendment to the pleadings, and that if the defense is treated as a constructive amendment, Rule 15’s prejudice standard governs and was met.
Documents: the brief (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: Amicus briefs; Supreme Court practice
American Securities Association v. SEC
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, No. 26-10936 (brief filed May 28, 2026)
Client: PTG Markets, amicus curiae supporting the petitioners, the American Securities Association and Citadel Securities
Role: Michael Showalter wrote the brief as counsel for PTG Markets.
What the brief argued: The petitioners challenge the SEC’s 2026 order funding the Consolidated Audit Trail, a database of equity and options trades. The brief argued that the major-questions doctrine and ordinary statutory interpretation foreclose the SEC’s claimed authority under Section 11A of the Exchange Act, and that the order is arbitrary and capricious because the SEC skipped the required economic analysis and ignored the incentive problems behind a decade of cost overruns.
Documents: the brief; the Eleventh Circuit’s earlier decision vacating the 2023 funding order, Am. Sec. Ass’n v. SEC, 147 F.4th 1264 (11th Cir. 2025).
Topic pages: SEC enforcement and securities regulation; Challenges to federal agency action; Amicus briefs
Boddie v. United States District Court for the District of Maryland
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 26-424 (brief filed October 28, 2026)
Client: A group of Sanctuary Belize lot purchasers, amici curiae supporting the petitioner
Role: Michael Showalter wrote the brief and filed it as counsel of record.
What the brief argued: A federal receiver’s sale order ended the lot purchase contracts of buyers who had paid tens of thousands of dollars or more, though the order does not say the receiver gave them notice of the sale motion. The brief argued that due process required notice by mail or email to buyers whose addresses the receiver had, and that because the order bound the buyers, they were entitled to be heard and to appeal.
Documents: the docket; the brief.
Topic pages: Amicus briefs; Supreme Court practice; Constitutional litigation
Thomson Reuters Enterprise Centre GmbH v. ROSS Intelligence Inc.
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 25-2153 (brief filed November 10, 2026, at the rehearing stage)
Client: DingDuff Inc., amicus curiae supporting ROSS Intelligence’s petition for rehearing
Role: Michael Showalter wrote the brief and filed it as counsel of record.
What the brief argued: The panel held that ROSS’s use of Westlaw headnotes to train an AI legal-search tool was not fair use, relying on lost Westlaw subscriptions. The brief argued from copyright’s first principles: copyright protects authors against copies that take the place of their work, and every harm the panel found was ordinary competition from a tool that showed users no headnotes at all.
Documents: the brief; the docket.
Topic pages: AI, technology, and copyright; Amicus briefs
Zabel v. Sanchez
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 26-2818 (opening brief filed June 15, 2026; reply brief filed August 27, 2026), from the Central District of California, No. 2:25-cv-05558
Client: Alanna Zabel, appellant
Role: Michael Showalter wrote the opening and reply briefs as counsel for the appellant.
What the brief argued: The district court dismissed Ms. Zabel’s copyright suit under the two-dismissal rule of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1)(B), which turns a plaintiff’s second voluntary dismissal of the same claim into a judgment on the merits. The opening brief argued that the rule never triggered, for four independent reasons. First, the earlier dismissed suit was in state court, and federal courts have exclusive jurisdiction over copyright claims, 28 U.S.C. § 1338(a), so that suit could not have included the same claim. Second, the later dismissal came by court order under Rule 41(a)(2), not by a self-executing notice under Rule 41(a)(1). Third, that dismissal was not voluntary, because Ms. Zabel, then without a lawyer, dismissed under pressure from opposing counsel’s threatened anti-SLAPP motion, which carried mandatory one-way attorney’s fees. Fourth, the rule cannot extinguish claims for infringing sales and displays that occurred after the earlier suits ended. The brief also argued that the rule cannot protect the publisher and the distributor, whom Ms. Zabel had never sued before. The reply brief showed that the answering brief’s waiver argument rested on a hallucinated quotation. The answering brief quoted Peterson v. Highland Music, Inc., 140 F.3d 1313 (9th Cir. 1998), as holding that “a new theory in support of an issue” is forfeited if it was not raised below, and it marked those words “emphasis added.” Peterson contains no such phrase. On September 1, 2026, the appellees moved to file a corrected answering brief, calling the error a phrase “mistakenly identified as a quote,” and the correction deleted the quotation marks, the pincite, and the “emphasis added.” An “emphasis added” notation presupposes words quoted from a source, and here there were none. The rest of the answering brief carries the marks of unchecked AI drafting. It repeatedly pairs a verb with its opposite: the denial of a stay motion “confirms—rather than refutes—that the case was already over”; Taylor v. Sturgell “confirms rather than defeats this result”; the opposing rule would end up “propagating rather than curtailing litigation”; and Rose Court “relied upon rather than overturned” an earlier decision. It also prints one citation twice in a row: “Media Rights Techs., Inc. v. Microsoft Corp., 922 F.3d 1014 (9th Cir. 2019), 922 F.3d 1014, 1023 (9th Cir. 2019).”
Documents: the opening and reply briefs; the Ninth Circuit docket, No. 26-2818; the appellees’ motion to file a corrected answering brief.
Topic pages: New appellate counsel after a loss below; AI, technology, and copyright
Stuart v. BABC Inc.
Court and docket: Circuit Court for Prince William County, Virginia, No. CL26003972-00
Client: Collin Stuart, plaintiff, who lent money to a home-renovation company
Role: Michael Showalter represented the plaintiff, with Virginia co-counsel Peter Zuk of Whiteford, Taylor & Preston.
What the brief argued: The company sold the renovated property without repaying the loan, and its owner was moving the company’s money out of reach. The verified complaint sued the company and its owner, who had guaranteed the loan, and challenged the transfers as fraudulent conveyances under Virginia law. The emergency motion asked the court to freeze the defendants’ assets without first notifying them, because notice would have given them time to move the money.
Result: On May 6, 2026, the court granted the ex parte motion for a temporary restraining order, finding “potential irreparable harm unless Defendants are restrained from dissipating the assets.” The order barred the company and its owner from transferring or encumbering assets beyond ordinary living expenses, from paying the owner’s personal expenses or salary out of company funds, and from settling company debts for less than the full amount. Virginia law treats any injunction as an extraordinary remedy, see Levisa Coal Co. v. Consolidation Coal Co., 276 Va. 44 (2008), and an ex parte order, entered before the other side is heard, is rarer still. The company never answered the complaint, and on August 7, 2026, the court entered a default judgment against it for $121,523.80, the full principal and interest owed, plus attorney’s fees.
Documents: the verified complaint, the temporary restraining order, and the default judgment.
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Matters at Wiley Rein
SEC v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024)
Supreme Court, 2024. Amicus brief for three telecommunications trade associations; the Court held that the defendants “are entitled to a jury trial in an Article III court.”
Calcutt v. FDIC, 598 U.S. 623 (2023) (per curiam)
Supreme Court, 2023. Amicus brief for the American Association of Bank Directors; the Court granted review and summarily reversed.
Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, 603 U.S. 799 (2024)
Supreme Court, 2024. The Cato Institute’s amicus briefs at the certiorari and merits stages; the Court reversed.
Hikvision USA, Inc. v. FCC, 97 F.4th 938 (D.C. Cir. 2024)
D.C. Circuit, 2024. Brief for Motorola Solutions as intervenor supporting the FCC; the court held that the Secure Equipment Act “ratified the composition of the Covered List.”
TikTok Inc. v. Garland
D.C. Circuit, 2024. Amicus brief for former FCC Chairman Ajit V. Pai and Thomas P. Feddo supporting the government; the court upheld the law, and the Supreme Court affirmed.
Franklin Armory, Inc. v. Garland
District of North Dakota, 2025. Summary judgment brief for Franklin Armory; the court granted summary judgment against ATF’s firearm classifications.
McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates, Inc. v. McKesson Corp.
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-1226 (brief filed December 26, 2024)
Client: CTIA, NCTA, USTelecom, and the Wireless Infrastructure Association, amici curiae supporting the respondents
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter co-drafted the brief.
What the brief argued: The brief argued that the Hobbs Act channels challenges to final FCC orders into direct review in a court of appeals within 60 days, which gives communications companies the predictable, nationwide rules they depend on. It argued that a private plaintiff may not use a later lawsuit to attack an FCC order’s validity and expand liability.
Documents: the brief (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Challenges to federal agency action; Amicus briefs
LTD Broadband LLC v. FCC
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, No. 24-1017 (argued November 5, 2024)
Client: LTD Broadband LLC, petitioner
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of LTD’s briefs and argued the case in the D.C. Circuit.
What the brief argued: LTD won about $1.3 billion in the FCC’s Rural Digital Opportunity Fund auction to bring broadband to roughly 528,000 rural locations, and the FCC then rejected its application. LTD argued that the FCC applied a heightened level of scrutiny to its application that the auction rules did not allow, and asked the court to send the denial back to the agency.
Documents: the D.C. Circuit’s judgment; Broadband Breakfast’s coverage of the argument
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Challenges to federal agency action
New York State Telecommunications Ass’n v. James
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 24-161 (brief filed September 13, 2024)
Client: The Chamber of Commerce of the United States, amicus curiae supporting the petitioners
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: New York’s Affordable Broadband Act requires internet providers to sell low-income households broadband at capped prices. The brief argued that the Communications Act of 1934 reaches all interstate communication by wire or radio and excludes intrastate service, the same structure the Court had read in earlier statutes to displace state regulation, so federal authority over interstate communications is exclusive and preempts New York’s rate regulation.
Documents: the brief; the docket
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Supreme Court practice; Amicus briefs
Rodriguez v. Exxon Mobil Corp.
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the District of Kansas, No. 2:25-cv-02195 (brief filed September 10, 2025)
Client: The Chamber of Commerce of the United States, amicus curiae supporting the defendants
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: Individuals and Ford County, Kansas, sued plastics producers and the American Chemistry Council, claiming the industry misled the public about recycling. The brief argued that the suit targets protected speech on a public issue, that public nuisance law has never reached the sale of lawful products, and that the claimed harm comes from third parties’ littering.
Result: The court dismissed the suit on September 29, 2026, holding that the plaintiffs, including the county, lacked standing.
Documents: the brief; the dismissal order
Topic pages: Amicus briefs; Business and employment litigation; Constitutional litigation
Northern Data AG v. Riot Platforms, Inc.
Court and docket: Delaware Court of Chancery, C.A. No. 2023-0650-LWW
Client: Northern Data AG, plaintiff, which sold a bitcoin-mining data-center business to Riot
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter developed Northern Data’s argument that the court should decide two disputed items itself instead of deferring to the accounting expert’s rulings under a manifest-error standard.
What the brief argued: After the sale, an independent accounting expert resolved disputes over the purchase price. Northern Data argued that two items, an allegedly double-billed receivable and a contested electricity invoice, were indemnification claims that raised legal questions outside the expert’s authority.
Result: On June 2, 2025, the Court of Chancery granted summary judgment to Northern Data on those two items, held that the expert lacked authority to decide them, and vacated his determinations.
Documents: the opinion
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Powell v. SEC
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 24-1899 (brief filed 2024)
Client: The Buckeye Institute, amicus curiae supporting the petitioners (pro bono)
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter helped draft the brief.
What the brief argued: The petitioners challenged the SEC’s “gag rule,” which bars defendants who settle SEC enforcement actions from publicly denying the allegations. The brief argued that the rule is a prior restraint that violates the First Amendment.
Documents: Wiley press release
Topic pages: SEC enforcement and securities regulation; Constitutional litigation; Amicus briefs
American Chemistry Council, Inc. v. Bonta
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 24-1139 (brief filed June 20, 2024)
Client: The Chamber of Commerce of the United States, the California Chamber of Commerce, the American Petroleum Institute, the Alliance for Automotive Innovation, CropLife America, and the National Mining Association, amici curiae supporting the plaintiff
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: California’s attorney general subpoenaed the American Chemistry Council for its communications with members about its recycling comments to the FTC. The brief argued that the subpoena threatened the association’s and its members’ First Amendment freedom to associate privately, targeted disfavored views, and was overbroad.
Result: The case ended on January 21, 2026, after California agreed to drop its demand for the association’s documents, including its communications with its members.
Documents: the brief; the Chamber’s case page
Topic pages: Constitutional litigation; Amicus briefs
Minnesota Telecom Alliance v. FCC
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, No. 24-1179 and consolidated cases
Client: Minnesota Telecom Alliance, one of the industry petitioners
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter helped draft the industry petitioners’ brief.
What the brief argued: The FCC’s digital discrimination rule, adopted under the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, made broadband providers liable for policies with disparate effects on protected groups. The industry petitioners argued that the statute reaches only intentional discrimination and that the rule covered entities the statute does not.
Result: On May 6, 2026, the Eighth Circuit held that the FCC “exceeded its statutory authority” by authorizing disparate impact liability and defining the covered entities too broadly, and vacated the rule.
Documents: the opinion
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Challenges to federal agency action
DIRECTV, LLC v. Nexstar Media Group, Inc.
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, No. 24-981
Client: Mission Broadcasting, Inc., appellee
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of Mission’s brief.
What the brief argued: DIRECTV sued broadcasters over retransmission-consent fees, alleging a price-fixing conspiracy. Mission’s brief argued that DIRECTV lacked antitrust standing to bring the claims.
Documents: the opinion
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Grand Trunk Corp. v. TSA
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, No. 24-2109 (opening brief filed November 27, 2024)
Client: Grand Trunk Corporation and Illinois Central Railroad Company (CN), petitioners
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of CN’s briefs.
What the brief argued: TSA issued railroad cybersecurity directives without notice-and-comment rulemaking by invoking an emergency exemption, 49 U.S.C. § 114(l)(2). CN argued that a long-running cyber threat is not an emergency within the meaning of the statute, so TSA had to use ordinary rulemaking.
Documents: the opinion
Topic pages: Challenges to federal agency action
Baxter v. Kennedy
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, No. 24-1203
Client: Dr. Timothy Baxter, plaintiff-appellant
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: The Department of Health and Human Services excluded Dr. Baxter from Medicare and Medicaid based on a prior conviction. The brief argued, drawing on the Supreme Court’s categorical-approach cases, that the Department’s reading of the exclusion statute was untenable.
Documents: the Fourth Circuit docket, No. 24-1203
Topic pages: Challenges to federal agency action
Impossible X LLC v. Impossible Foods Inc.
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-874 (petition filed February 12, 2024), from the Ninth Circuit, No. 21-16977
Client: Impossible X LLC, petitioner
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of Impossible X’s Ninth Circuit brief and its petition for certiorari.
What the brief argued: The Ninth Circuit held that California courts had personal jurisdiction over Impossible X in a trademark dispute, though the company had left California years earlier. The petition asked whether Ford Motor Co. v. Montana Eighth Judicial District Court, 592 U.S. 351 (2021), eliminated any need for a link between a defendant’s forum contacts and the plaintiff’s injury, and whether only enforcement-related contacts count in a suit for a declaration of noninfringement.
Documents: the petition; the docket
Topic pages: Supreme Court practice; Business and employment litigation
AT&T, Inc. v. FCC and the related location-data forfeiture cases
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 24-60223 (brief filed August 5, 2024), with the Chamber’s briefs in the companion cases
Client: The Chamber of Commerce of the United States, amicus curiae supporting the carriers
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the Chamber’s briefs.
What the brief argued: The FCC fined AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile and Sprint nearly $200 million combined over customer location data. The Chamber argued that, under SEC v. Jarkesy, imposing civil penalties through in-house proceedings without a jury violates the Seventh Amendment, and that the FCC used new readings of the Communications Act to punish conduct no rule prohibited when it occurred.
Documents: the Chamber’s case page
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Challenges to federal agency action; Constitutional litigation; Amicus briefs
Gurung v. MetaQuotes Ltd.
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, No. 25-328, from the Eastern District of New York, No. 1:23-cv-06362
Client: MetaQuotes Ltd. and MetaQuotes Software Corp., defendants-appellees
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was one of the two lead drafters of MetaQuotes’ Second Circuit brief.
What the brief argued: A victim of a “pig butchering” investment scam sued MetaQuotes, whose MetaTrader platform software the scammers used, under RICO and aiding-and-abetting theories. MetaQuotes argued that a software provider is not liable for fraud that others commit using its platform.
Documents: the district court docket
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Matters at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher
Dakota Access Pipeline: Standing Rock Sioux Tribe v. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
D.C. Circuit and Supreme Court, 2020–2021. Dakota Access’s appeal, stay motion, and certiorari petition; the D.C. Circuit stayed and then reversed the order to shut down the pipeline.
Puntenney v. Iowa Utilities Board
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 19-447 (brief in opposition filed January 6, 2020), from the Iowa Supreme Court, 928 N.W.2d 829 (Iowa 2019)
Client: Dakota Access, LLC (Energy Transfer), respondent
Role: As an associate at Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter drafted the brief.
What the brief argued: Iowa landowners asked the Supreme Court to hold that Iowa’s use of eminent domain for the Dakota Access Pipeline failed the Takings Clause’s public-use requirement. The brief in opposition argued that the Iowa Supreme Court’s decision was “a straightforward—and correct—application of settled authority,” that no court had rejected its reasoning, and that the case was a poor vehicle.
Result: The Supreme Court denied review on February 24, 2020, leaving Dakota Access’s win in the Iowa Supreme Court in place.
Documents: the brief in opposition (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: Energy, pipelines, and environmental review; Supreme Court practice; Constitutional litigation
Strang v. Ford Motor Co. General Retirement Plan
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 17-528 (brief in opposition filed December 11, 2017), from the Sixth Circuit, No. 16-2090
Client: Ford Motor Company General Retirement Plan and the other respondents
Role: As an associate at Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter drafted the brief.
What the brief argued: The petitioner sought to recover pension benefits through ERISA’s catch-all equitable remedy, Section 502(a)(3), on the theory that the plan breached a fiduciary duty by not paying them. The brief argued that every circuit allows Section 502(a)(3) claims only for breaches other than the denial of benefits, because Section 502(a)(1)(B) already provides the remedy for unpaid benefits, and that the claim would fail on the merits in any event.
Result: The Supreme Court denied review on June 25, 2018, leaving Ford’s Sixth Circuit win in place.
Documents: the brief in opposition (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: Supreme Court practice; Business and employment litigation
Bovat v. Vermont
Supreme Court, 2020. Amicus brief for the Institute for Justice; Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Kagan, wrote that the Vermont court had erred.
Gibson v. SEC
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 20-276 (brief filed October 5, 2020)
Client: George R. Jarkesy, Jr., amicus curiae supporting the petitioner
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter was one of the brief’s two lead drafters.
What the brief argued: The brief argued that the Securities Exchange Act’s review provision, 15 U.S.C. § 78y, does not strip federal district courts of jurisdiction over constitutional challenges to SEC enforcement proceedings, and that without a district court forum, defendants face years of agency proceedings and pressure to settle before any court reviews the constitutionality of the process.
Result: The Court took up the same question three years later and reached the result the brief urged, holding that the SEC’s and FTC’s review schemes do not displace district court jurisdiction over structural constitutional challenges to their proceedings. Axon Enterprise, Inc. v. FTC, 598 U.S. 175 (2023).
Documents: the brief; the docket
Topic pages: SEC enforcement and securities regulation; Supreme Court practice; Amicus briefs
Cochise Consultancy, Inc. v. United States ex rel. Hunt
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 18-315 (merits brief filed January 2, 2019)
Client: Cochise Consultancy, Inc. and The Parsons Corporation, petitioners
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the brief.
What the brief argued: The case asked whether the False Claims Act’s three-year limitations period, which runs from when the government knew or should have known the facts, applies to a whistleblower’s suit the government declines to join. The petitioners argued that it does not, so the outer limit is six years from the violation.
Documents: the petitioners’ brief (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
Topic pages: Supreme Court practice; Business and employment litigation
Uber’s challenge to California Assembly Bill 5: Olson v. California
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, No. 2:19-cv-10956; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 21-55757
Client: Uber Technologies, Inc., with Postmates and individual drivers, plaintiffs
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter drafted the plaintiffs’ preliminary injunction briefing.
What the brief argued: The plaintiffs’ motion for a preliminary injunction challenged AB 5, California’s worker-classification law, arguing that its many exemptions for other industries singled out app-based drivers and couriers in violation of the Equal Protection Clause and related constitutional guarantees.
Documents: the district court docket, where the motion is entry 14.
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation; Constitutional litigation
Palmer v. Amazon.com, Inc.
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, No. 1:20-cv-02468
Client: Amazon.com, Inc., defendant
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter identified and developed Amazon’s argument that New York’s workers’ compensation law bars suits for injunctive relief as well as suits for damages. Every court to consider the question, and the leading treatises, had read the law the other way. Michael built the argument from the statute’s original meaning: the 1914 law makes the employer’s compensation liability “exclusive” and “in place of any other liability whatsoever,” and Black’s Law Dictionary (1910) defined liability to include obligations enforced in equity.
What the brief argued: Warehouse workers sued Amazon over its COVID-19 workplace safety practices early in the pandemic and asked for an injunction. Amazon’s motion to dismiss argued that the workplace safety agency, OSHA, should decide the questions first and, in the alternative, that the workers’ compensation law barred the claims, including the claim for an injunction.
Result: The district court dismissed the suit on November 2, 2020, and held that the workers’ compensation law bars the workers’ claim for injunctive relief for past harm. The Second Circuit later rejected that holding. Palmer v. Amazon.com, Inc., 51 F.4th 491 (2d Cir. 2022). In Palmer v. Amazon: A Case Study in Textualism and the Fixed-Meaning Canon, 14 Wake Forest L. Rev. Online 112 (2024), Michael explained why that decision is indefensible.
Documents: the Second Circuit opinion; Michael’s Wake Forest Law Review article.
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Turchrome award enforcement: Turchrome Krom Madencili Sanay Ve Dis Ticaret Limited Sirketi v. Cevik
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, No. 1:19-cv-22910, removed from and remanded to the Circuit Court for Miami-Dade County, No. 19-09205-CA-47
Client: Turchrome, which held the arbitration award
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter worked on Turchrome’s effort to enforce a $388 million International Chamber of Commerce arbitration award against Mustafa Cevik and Sefa Cevik.
What the brief argued: Turchrome sued in Florida state court to enforce the award. The Ceviks removed the case to federal court, and Turchrome moved to send it back to state court.
Result: The federal court remanded the case to state court at Turchrome’s request on February 10, 2020.
Documents: the federal docket; Law360’s case page.
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Principal Life Insurance Co. v. Rozo
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 19-1462 (brief filed July 20, 2020)
Client: The Stable Value Investment Association, amicus curiae supporting the petitioner
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: The Eighth Circuit held that two common features of stable value products, crediting rates that reset each period and limits on plan-level withdrawals, made the insurer an ERISA fiduciary. The brief argued that the ruling split from other circuits and threatened the stable value industry, which holds more than 10 percent of defined contribution plan assets.
Documents: the brief; the docket
Topic pages: Supreme Court practice; Amicus briefs; Business and employment litigation
Cipla Ltd. v. Amgen Inc.
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 19-2017, from the District of Delaware, No. 1:19-cv-00044
Client: Amgen Inc.
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of Amgen’s emergency briefing in the district court and the Third Circuit.
What the brief argued: Amgen sued Cipla for breaching their patent settlement by launching a generic version of Sensipar (cinacalcet) early, and sought a preliminary injunction to stop the launch.
Documents: the Third Circuit opinion; the district court opinion
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Oakley v. Dolan
Court and docket: U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 1:17-cv-06903
Client: James Dolan and the Madison Square Garden defendants
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the motion to dismiss.
What the brief argued: Former Knicks player Charles Oakley sued after his removal from Madison Square Garden in February 2017. The motion argued that his assault, disability-discrimination, defamation, and other claims failed as a matter of law.
Result: The district court dismissed the complaint in 2020, and the Second Circuit affirmed the dismissal of every claim except assault and battery.
Documents: the district court docket, No. 1:17-cv-06903
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
McIntyre v. RealPage, Inc.
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, No. 20-8035 (Rule 23(f) petition, 2020), from the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, No. 2:18-cv-03934
Client: RealPage, Inc., defendant-petitioner
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the petition.
What the brief argued: A tenant-screening class action under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The petition asked the Third Circuit to review the district court’s certification of a class.
Documents: the district court docket
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
Fitisemanu v. United States
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, No. 20-4017
Client: John Fitisemanu and other American Samoans living in Utah, plaintiffs-appellees
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the brief.
What the brief argued: People born in American Samoa, a U.S. territory, are treated by federal law as U.S. nationals but not citizens. The brief defended the district court’s ruling that the Fourteenth Amendment’s Citizenship Clause makes them citizens at birth.
Documents: the Tenth Circuit opinion
Topic pages: Constitutional litigation
Brackeen v. Bernhardt
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, No. 18-11479
Client: Chad and Jennifer Brackeen and the other individual plaintiffs, adoptive and prospective adoptive families
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the Fifth Circuit briefing.
What the brief argued: The families challenged the Indian Child Welfare Act. They argued that its placement preferences are racial classifications that fail strict scrutiny, that the Act exceeds Congress’s power, and that it commandeers state agencies and courts.
Documents: the en banc opinion; the individual plaintiffs’ panel brief
Topic pages: Constitutional litigation
Outlaw Beverage, Inc. v. Collins
Court and docket: Delaware Court of Chancery, C.A. No. 2019-0342-AGB
Client: Lance Collins and A Shoc Beverage, LLC, defendants
Role: At Gibson Dunn, Michael Showalter helped draft the defendants’ briefing.
What the brief argued: Outlaw Beverage sued its co-founder, Lance Collins, and his new company to block the launch of the A Shoc energy drink, claiming Collins had taken its brand, design, and formula. The defendants opposed Outlaw’s motion for a preliminary injunction.
Result: In June 2019, the Court of Chancery denied the preliminary injunction.
Documents: Ross Aronstam & Moritz’s case page; BevNET’s coverage
Topic pages: Business and employment litigation
