Matters at Wiley Rein
Calcutt v. FDIC, 598 U.S. 623 (2023) (per curiam)
Court and docket: Supreme Court of the United States, No. 22-714 (brief filed March 3, 2023)
Client: The American Association of Bank Directors, amicus curiae supporting the petitioner
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: The Sixth Circuit had found serious legal errors in the FDIC’s decision but upheld a lifetime banking ban and $125,000 in penalties on its own review of the record. The brief argued that under the Chenery doctrine a court must judge agency action only on the grounds the agency invoked, and that the panel’s approach would embolden regulators and deter qualified people from serving as bank directors.
Result: The Supreme Court granted review at the certiorari stage and summarily reversed, holding that the Sixth Circuit should have sent the case back to the FDIC instead of upholding the sanctions on a legal theory the agency had not applied.
Documents: the brief (supremecourt.gov); the docket; the opinion (CourtListener).
Topic pages: Challenges to federal agency action; Supreme Court practice; Amicus briefs; New appellate counsel after a loss below
