Matters at Wiley Rein
Hikvision USA, Inc. v. FCC, 97 F.4th 938 (D.C. Cir. 2024)
Court and docket: U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, No. 23-1032 (Motorola’s final brief filed September 19, 2023; free on CourtListener at storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cadc.39551/gov.uscourts.cadc.39551.1208554036.0.pdf)
Client: Motorola Solutions, Inc., intervenor supporting the FCC
Role: At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the brief.
What the brief argued: Hikvision and Dahua challenged the FCC order barring authorization of their video-surveillance equipment as a national security risk. Motorola’s brief argued that the challenge to the companies’ placement on the FCC’s Covered List came too late, and that Congress had ratified the Covered List in the Secure Equipment Act of 2021, which foreclosed that challenge. It also defended the FCC’s reading of “critical infrastructure.”
Result: The D.C. Circuit decided the companies’ lead challenge on the ratification ground. It held that the Secure Equipment Act “ratified the composition of the Covered List and leaves no room for Petitioners to challenge the placement of their products on that list,” and it upheld the FCC’s order to the extent it bars authorization of Hikvision’s and Dahua’s equipment used for physical security surveillance of critical infrastructure.
Documents: the opinion (CourtListener).
Topic pages: FCC, telecommunications, and national security; Challenges to federal agency action
