Matters at Wiley Rein
SEC v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024): amicus brief for three telecommunications trade associations
At Wiley Rein, Michael Showalter was the lead drafter of the Supreme Court amicus brief of CTIA—The Wireless Association, USTelecom—The Broadband Association, and the Competitive Carriers Association in SEC v. Jarkesy, a brief that made arguments ultimately advanced by Justice Neil Gorsuch in a concurring opinion.
| Matter facts | |
|---|---|
| Court | Supreme Court of the United States |
| Docket number | No. 22-859 |
| Brief filed | October 18, 2023 |
| Decided | June 27, 2024 (judgment affirmed) |
| Citation | 603 U.S. 109 |
| Amici | CTIA—The Wireless Association; USTelecom—The Broadband Association; Competitive Carriers Association |
| Counsel on the brief | Thomas M. Johnson, Jr. (counsel of record), Jeremy J. Broggi, Michael J. Showalter, and Joel S. Nolette, Wiley Rein LLP |
What the brief argued
The brief argued that Article III, the Due Process Clause, and the Seventh Amendment together require the government to go to court, before a jury, when it seeks to take private property through civil penalties. It argued that Atlas Roofing had been “effectively repudiated,” that agencies wrongly “combine the roles of prosecutor, judge, and jury under a single roof,” and that the Constitution guarantees judicial process “no matter the inconvenience to the government.”
What the Court did
The Court agreed with the brief’s central position. The SEC may not use its in-house tribunal to seek civil penalties for securities fraud, because the defendants “are entitled to a jury trial in an Article III court.” 603 U.S. at 140. Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justice Thomas, wrote separately and advanced the brief’s broader arguments, often in nearly the same words.
Same arguments, nearly the same words
| The CTIA brief | The Court |
|---|---|
| “Article III, the Due Process Clause, and most relevant here, the Seventh Amendment” together require court process. Br. 3. | The jury right “does not work alone. It operates together with Article III and the Due Process Clause.” 603 U.S. at 141 (Gorsuch, J., concurring). |
| Atlas Roofing “has since been heavily criticized by scholars and effectively repudiated by this Court.” Br. 3. | Rejects “the government’s overbroad reading of Atlas Roofing” and the “atextual and ahistorical (not to mention confusing) tests it inspired.” Id. at 158 (Gorsuch, J., concurring). |
| “The Seventh Amendment should be treated no differently than other provisions” of the Constitution. Br. 18 n.10. | “This Court does not subject other constitutional rights to such shabby treatment.” Id. at 158 (Gorsuch, J., concurring). |
| Defendants are owed judicial process “no matter the inconvenience to the government.” Br. 30. | The Constitution never let the Executive reassign cases to tribunals where “inconvenient juries and traditional trial procedures go by the boards.” Id. at 161 (Gorsuch, J., concurring). |
| Agencies “combine the roles of prosecutor, judge, and jury under a single roof.” Br. 4. | The dissent “would permit Congress to concentrate the roles of prosecutor, judge, and jury in the hands of the Executive Branch.” Id. at 140 (majority opinion). |
Documents: the brief (supremecourt.gov); the docket.
